Not sure if the black pair are made by someone else, but they are extremely tight around my feet to the point I really considered sending them back (both colors size 11-12). They fit about anywhere and don?t take up much space. Im not paying super premium prices for a tiny lil thing that will be broken soon. Looks and feels great! Additionally, the construction seemed weak because it was not a solid piece but molded with lots of cut-out open voids on the underside. As for the fit, it depends on the actual size of your feet. But they are incredibly bright. Tengono il piede fresco, sono facili da tenere pulite. This nightgown is just beautiful. Now the larger size fits perfectly, and the shoes feel much more comfortable and supportive than without insoles.