still 5-stars for sure. I normally wear an 8 in most shoes and Crocs. They are very comfortable, but I do recommend sizing down a half size with these, especially if you have small/narrow feet like mine. The holes for the bench dont line up with the brackets The metal material is extremely thin and easy to bend. The toe strap is covered with the same soft material the bows are made of, so they are very comfortable. The ingredients in this are effective for for the skin. Lifter interface for desk phones is a little annoying. I like keen shoes for the wider toe box, but the size I normally wear slid up and down on my heels. This is a really cheap quality product!